individual bun and butter pudding.jpg

Individual bun and butter puddings

This recipe is so good that you’ll want to let your Hot Cross Buns go stale just to make it.

How long will it take?

50 minutes

What’s the serving size?

Serves 4-6


What do I need?

  • 4-6 hot cross buns, halved
  • A dab of butter for each bun and your dish
  • 250ml light milk
  • 250ml cream
  • Seeds from 1/2 vanilla pod or 1 tsp vanilla extract
  • ½ tsp mixed spice
  • 2 eggs
  • 75g caster sugar
  • Zest of 1 orange
  • A handful of dried fruit, chopped if needed

How do I make it?

  1. Lightly butter 4-6 ramekins or a baking dish which will hold your buns in a single layer.
  2. Toast your buns. Butter the insides like you would normally.
  3. Add the milk, cream, vanilla and mixed spice to a saucepan. Warm through.
  4. Whisk the eggs, sugar and orange zest till pale. Pour the warm milk/cream mix over. Whip till it thickens a bit. Add your buns to the mix so they’re coated.
  5. Arrange the bottom halves of each bun in your dishes. Scatter a good pinch of dried fruit over each one. Pop the top half on. Pour enough custard over to come just over half way up. Let the buns soak for 15 mins before baking.
  6. Bake till golden on top and the custard is thick, about 30 mins.
  7. Sieve the remaining custard into a saucepan. Cook over medium-low heat, whisking constantly, till thickened to your liking. Serve the puddings with warm custard on the side.
  8. If you have leftover custard, turn it into ice cream. Freeze in a shallow metal dish (whisking a few times to break up the ice crystals) until firm and deliciously ice cream-ish. Or use an ice cream maker.

Share this recipe


More recipes like this

almond_cake_with_poached_pears.jpg
Almond Cake with Poached Pears
Almond_Tangelo_Upside_Down_Cake_2.jpg
Almond Tangelo Upside Down Cake
almond_toffee_sea_salt_brownies.jpg
Almond toffee sea salt brownies
ginger_biscuit_and_apple_frangipane_tart.jpg
Ginger Biscuit and Apple Frangipane Tart
aussie_pavlova.jpg
Aussie Pavlova
baked_salted_caramel_banoffee_tarts.jpg
Baked Salted Caramel Banoffee Tarts
very_berry_cheesecake.jpg
Very berry cheesecake
hellenic_mess.jpg
Hellenic Mess
kiwi_coconut_and_watermelon_pops.jpg
Kiwi, coconut and watermelon pops
lamington_macarons.jpg
Lamington Macarons
pina_colada_nice_cream.jpg
Pina Colada Nice Cream
silky_chocolate_and_raspberry_tart.jpg
Silky Chocolate and Raspberry Tart
strawberry_mascarpone_cake.jpg
Strawberry and Mascarpone Cream Layer Cake
tiramisu_popsicles.jpg
Tiramisu Popsicles
nectarine_granita_with_blueberries.jpg
Nectarine granita with blueberries
waffles_with_valhalla_ice_cream.jpg
Homemade waffles with Valhalla Ice Cream
watermelon_cake.jpg
Watermelon Cake
baked_cheesecake_with_summer_berries.jpg
Baked cheesecake with summer berries
watermleon_strawberry_and_coconut_panna_cotta.jpg
Watermelon, Strawberry and Coconut Panna Cotta
white_chocolate_and_raspberry_brownies.jpg
White Chocolate and Raspberry Brownies (Blondies)
zesty_strawberries_with_cointreau.jpg
Zesty strawberries with Cointreau
banana_bites_frozen.jpg
Frozen banana bites
banana_pudding_with_meringue.jpg
Homemade southern banana pudding with meringue
Kiwi_mint_and_lime_ice-cream_pops.jpg
Kiwi, mint and lime ice-cream pops
boozy_christmas_popsicles.jpg
Boozy Christmas popsicles
bread_and_butter_pudding.jpg
Bread and Butter Pudding
Lamington_ice-cream_pops.jpg
Lamington ice-cream pops
Strawberry_and_vanilla_panna_cotta_with_white_chocolate_popcorn.jpg
Strawberry and vanilla panna cotta with white chocolate popcorn
turkish_delight.jpg
Turkish Delight
plum_cake.jpg
Plum cake
rockmelon_granita.jpg
Rockmelon granita
Lemon_Meringue_Pie.jpg
Lemon meringue pie
Poached_pear_with_chocolate_sauce.jpg
Poached pear with chocolate sauce
hot_cross_bun_icecream.jpg
Hot Cross Bun Ice Cream
hot_cross_bun_trifle.jpg
Hot Cross Bun Trifle
individual_bun_and_butter_pudding.jpg
Individual bun and butter puddings
vegan_carrot_cake.jpg
Vegan Carrot Cake
Mandarin_Almond_and_Chocolate_Cake.jpg
Mandarin, almond and chocolate cake
truffles.jpg
Chocolate Truffles
crepes_suzette.jpg
Crêpes Suzette
eclairs.jpg
Eclairs with crème patisserie
queen_of_puddings.jpg
Queen of Puddings
Molten_chocolate_lava_cakes.jpg
Molten chocolate lava cakes
Pistachio_and_Green_Tea_cake.jpg
Pistachio green tea cake
Choc_hazelnut_brownies_with_chocolate_drizzle.jpg
Choc hazelnut brownies with chocolate drizzle
Coconut_cream_white_chocolate_and_kiwi_fruit_tartlets.jpg
Coconut cream, white chocolate and kiwi fruit tartlets
Chocolate_and_zucchini_loaf_cake.jpg
Chocolate and zucchini loaf cake
Lemon_lime_delicious.jpg
Lemon lime delicious
Coconut_slice_with_lemon_curd.jpg
Coconut slice with lemon curd
Marinated_figs_with_brie.jpg
Marinated figs with brie
Rhubarb_tart.jpg
Rhubarb tart
Choc-Hazelnut_Drip_Cake.jpg
Choc-hazelnut drip cake