individual bun and butter pudding.jpg

Individual bun and butter puddings

This recipe is so good that you’ll want to let your Hot Cross Buns go stale just to make it.

How long will it take?

50 minutes

What’s the serving size?

Serves 4-6


What do I need?

  • 4-6 hot cross buns, halved
  • A dab of butter for each bun and your dish
  • 250ml light milk
  • 250ml cream
  • Seeds from 1/2 vanilla pod or 1 tsp vanilla extract
  • ½ tsp mixed spice
  • 2 eggs
  • 75g caster sugar
  • Zest of 1 orange
  • A handful of dried fruit, chopped if needed

How do I make it?

  1. Lightly butter 4-6 ramekins or a baking dish which will hold your buns in a single layer.
  2. Toast your buns. Butter the insides like you would normally.
  3. Add the milk, cream, vanilla and mixed spice to a saucepan. Warm through.
  4. Whisk the eggs, sugar and orange zest till pale. Pour the warm milk/cream mix over. Whip till it thickens a bit. Add your buns to the mix so they’re coated.
  5. Arrange the bottom halves of each bun in your dishes. Scatter a good pinch of dried fruit over each one. Pop the top half on. Pour enough custard over to come just over half way up. Let the buns soak for 15 mins before baking.
  6. Bake till golden on top and the custard is thick, about 30 mins.
  7. Sieve the remaining custard into a saucepan. Cook over medium-low heat, whisking constantly, till thickened to your liking. Serve the puddings with warm custard on the side.
  8. If you have leftover custard, turn it into ice cream. Freeze in a shallow metal dish (whisking a few times to break up the ice crystals) until firm and deliciously ice cream-ish. Or use an ice cream maker.

Share this recipe


More recipes like this

pear_cake 3.jpg
Almond Cake with Poached Pears
Almond Tangelo Upside Down Cake 2.jpg
Almond Tangelo Upside Down Cake
almond toffee sea salt brownies 2.jpg
Almond toffee sea salt brownies
Ginger Biscuit and Apple Frangipane Tart 2.jpg
Ginger Biscuit and Apple Frangipane Tart
aussie-pavlova.jpg
Aussie Pavlova
baked_salted_caramel_banoffee_tarts.jpg
Baked Salted Caramel Banoffee Tarts
very-berry-cheesecake.jpg
Very berry cheesecake
hellenic_mess.jpg
Hellenic Mess
Kiwi_Coconut_and_Watermelon_Pops.jpg
Kiwi, coconut and watermelon pops
lamington macarons.jpg
Lamington Macarons
pina colada nice cream.jpg
Pina Colada Nice Cream
silky chocolate and raspberry tart.jpg
Silky Chocolate and Raspberry Tart
strawberry mascarpone cake.jpg
Strawberry and Mascarpone Cream Layer Cake
tiramisu popsicles.jpg
Tiramisu Popsicles
nectarine granita with blueberries.jpg
Nectarine granita with blueberries
waffles with valhalla ice cream.jpg
Homemade waffles with Valhalla Ice Cream
watermelon cake.jpg
Watermelon Cake
baked cheesecake with summer berries.jpg
Baked cheesecake with summer berries
watermleon strawberry and coconut panna cotta.jpg
Watermelon, Strawberry and Coconut Panna Cotta
white chocolate and raspberry brownies.jpg
White Chocolate and Raspberry Brownies (Blondies)
zesty strawberries with cointreau.jpg
Zesty strawberries with Cointreau
banana bites frozen.jpg
Frozen banana bites
banana pudding with meringue.jpg
Homemade southern banana pudding with meringue
Kiwi, mint and lime ice-cream pops.jpg
Kiwi, mint and lime ice-cream pops
boozy christmas popsicles.jpg
Boozy Christmas popsicles
bread and butter pudding.jpg
Bread and Butter Pudding
Lamington ice-cream pops.jpg
Lamington ice-cream pops
Strawberry and vanilla panna cotta with white chocolate popcorn.jpg
Strawberry and vanilla panna cotta with white chocolate popcorn
turkish delight.jpg
Turkish Delight
plum cake.jpg
Plum cake
rockmelon granita.jpg
Rockmelon granita
Lemon Meringue Pie.jpg
Lemon meringue pie
Poached pear with chocolate sauce.jpg
Poached pear with chocolate sauce
hot cross bun icecream.jpg
Hot Cross Bun Ice Cream
hot cross bun trifle.jpg
Hot Cross Bun Trifle
individual bun and butter pudding.jpg
Individual bun and butter puddings
vegan carrot cake.jpg
Vegan Carrot Cake
Mandarin, Almond and Chocolate Cake.jpg
Mandarin, almond and chocolate cake
truffles.jpg
Chocolate Truffles
crepes suzette.jpg
Crêpes Suzette
eclairs.jpg
Eclairs with crème patisserie
queen of puddings.jpg
Queen of Puddings
Molten chocolate lava cakes.jpg
Molten chocolate lava cakes
Pistachio and Green Tea cake.jpg
Pistachio green tea cake
Choc hazelnut brownies with chocolate drizzle.jpg
Choc hazelnut brownies with chocolate drizzle
Coconut cream, white chocolate and kiwi fruit tartlets.jpg
Coconut cream, white chocolate and kiwi fruit tartlets
Chocolate and zucchini loaf cake.jpg
Chocolate and zucchini loaf cake
Lemon lime delicious.jpg
Lemon lime delicious
Coconut slice with lemon curd.jpg
Coconut slice with lemon curd
Marinated figs with brie.jpg
Marinated figs with brie
Rhubarb tart.jpg
Rhubarb tart
Choc-Hazelnut Drip Cake.jpg
Choc-hazelnut drip cake
Berry Ice Cream Popsicles.jpg
Berry Ice Cream Popsicles
Festive white chocolate bark.jpg
White Chocolate bark
Sparkling Rose Jelly with Berries.jpg
Sparkling Rosé Jelly with Berries
Chocolate and Almond Cheesecake.jpg
Chocolate and almond cheesecake
Gingerbread Tiramisu Trifle Parfait.jpg
Gingerbread Tiramisu Trifle Parfaits
Raspberry and Pistachio Semifreddo.jpg
Raspberry and Pistachio Semifreddo
Summer Pudding Terrine.jpg
Summer Pudding Terrine
Raspberry marshmallows2.jpg
Raspberry Marshmallows
Coconut-Pineapple-peach-Trifle-dessert.jpg
Pineapple, Apricot and Coconut Trifle
Fruit Wands2.jpg
Fresh Fruit Wands with Yoghurt Dip
Marbled fridge cake.jpg
Marbled fridge cake
Yellow watermelon, honey and basil sorbet.jpg
Yellow watermelon, honey and basil sorbet
Chocolate coated cheesecake balls.jpg
Chocolate coated cheesecake balls
Hot Cross Bun Trifle.jpg
Hot Cross Bun Trifle
Hot Cross Doughnuts.jpg
Hot Cross Doughnuts
easter chocolate tart.jpg
Chocolate Easter Tart
Honey Roasted Pears with Mascarpone Cream and Nut Crumb.jpg
Honey Roasted Pears with Mascarpone Cream and Nut Crumb
Blueberry and Lemon Delight Cake.jpg
Blueberry and Lemon Delight Cake
Strawberry Skillet Cake.jpg
Strawberry Skillet Cake
Orange and Lemon Poppy Seed Cake.jpg
Orange and Lemon Poppy Seed Cake
carrot cake slice.jpg
Carrot Cake Slice
Three ingredient choc chip biscuits.jpg
Three ingredient choc chip biscuits
Lemon Polenta Syrup Slice.jpg
Lemon Polenta Syrup Slice
Pumpkin Pie.jpg
Pumpkin Pie
One-pot lentil bake with kale pesto.jpg
Red Berry Galette with Honeyed Yoghurt
Mandarin Cake.jpg
Mandarin Cake
Ultimate chocolate fudge cake.jpg
Ultimate chocolate fudge cake
Apple Tarte Tatin.jpg
Apple Tarte Tatin
Caramel Almond Popcorn.jpg
Caramel Almond Popcorn
Spiced Baked Apples.jpg
Spiced Baked Apples
Apple Fritters - Website Tile.jpg
Apple Fritters
Blueberry Scones.jpg
Blueberry Scones
Blood Orange and Yoghurt Loaf Cake.jpg
Blood Orange and Yoghurt Loaf Cake
Pecan Tarts.jpg
Nutty Brown Butter, Whisky and Pecan Tarts
Chia and Coconut Cups.jpg
Chia and Coconut Cups
Choc Orange Biscuits.jpg
Choc Orange Biscuits
Choc Ripple Baileys Fridge Cake.jpg
Choc Ripple Baileys Fridge Cake
Frozen White Christmas.jpg
Frozen White Christmas
Salted Caramel Roasted Pineapple.jpg
Salted Caramel Roasted Pineapple
Raspberry Terrine.jpg
Raspberry Terrine
Website Tile.jpg
Valhalla Low Sugar Wafflewiches
Roasted Banana and Caramel Ice-cream.jpg
Roasted Banana and Caramel Ice-cream
Cherry Cranberry Christmas Pops.jpg
Cherry Cranberry Christmas Pops
Classic Cloth-Boiled Christmas Pudding.jpg
Classic Cloth-Boiled Christmas Pudding
Frozen Christmas Pudding.jpg
Frozen Christmas Pudding
Gin and Tonic Tart.jpg
Gin and Tonic Tart
Honey Grilled Peaches.jpg
Honey Grilled Peaches
Modern Christmas Cake.jpg
Modern Christmas Cake
Orange Cheesecake.jpg
Orange Cheesecake
Peach Trifle.jpg
Peach Trifle
Chocolate Covered Shortbread Biscuits with Hazelnuts and Sea Salt.jpg
Chocolate Covered Shortbread Biscuits with Hazelnuts and Sea Salt
Fruit Salad Ice Pops.jpg
Fruit Salad Ice Pops
Mango Coconut Balls.jpg
Mango Coconut Balls
Watermelon, Mint, Lime and Coconut Sorbet.jpg
Watermelon, Mint, Lime and Coconut Sorbet
Cherry Pie.jpg
Cherry Pie
Rockmelon Ice Cream.jpg
Rockmelon Ice Cream
Homemade fruity muesli bars.jpg
Homemade Fruity Muesli Bars
Molten Chocolate Lava Cakes v2.jpg
Molten Chocolate Lava Cakes
Website Tile - Hummingbird Cake.jpg
Hummingbird Cake
Website Tile - Chocolate Babka.jpg
Chocolate Babka
Baked Caramel Pears.jpg
Baked Caramel Pears
Raspberry and White Chocolate Pudding.jpg
Raspberry and White Chocolate Pudding
Gin and Tonic Loaf Cake.jpg
Gin and Tonic Loaf Cake
Banoffee Pie.jpg
Banoffee Pie
Website Tile - S'mores Cheesecake.jpg
S'mores Cheesecake
Pear Cake.jpg
Pear Cake
Apricot and Coconut Slice.jpg
Apricot and Coconut Slice
Mandarin Sour Cream Custard Cake.jpg
Mandarin Sour Cream Custard Cake
French Apple Cake.jpg
French Apple Cake
Pineapple Curd and Coconut Cupcakes.jpg
Pineapple Curd and Coconut Cupcakes
Chocolate Mug Cake.jpg
Easy Chocolate Mug Cake
Jaffa Mousse.jpg
Jaffa Mousse
Apple and Cinnamon Pull-Apart Loaf.jpg
Apple and Cinnamon Pull-Apart Loaf
Website Tile - Blueberry Pie.jpg
Blueberry Pie
Chocolate coated pretzels.jpg
Chocolate Coated Pretzels
Tangelo and Poppy Seed Mini Bundt Cakes.jpg
Tangelo and Poppy Seed Mini Bundt Cakes
Candied Bacon Rocky Road.jpg
Candied Bacon Rocky Road
Pineapple Upside Down Cake.jpg
Pineapple Upside Down Cake
Website Tile - Japanese Cheesecake with Salted Caramel Sauce.jpg
Japanese Cheesecake with Salted Caramel Sauce
Honeydew Sorbet.jpg
Honeydew Sorbet
Flourless Chocolate Cake.jpg
Flourless Chocolate Cake
Blood orange upside-down cake.jpg
Blood orange upside-down cake
Blushing Strawberry Gin Profiterole Trifle.jpg
Blushing Strawberry Gin Profiterole Trifle
Ice Cream Panettone.jpg
Ice Cream Panettone
Website Tiles - Christmas11.jpg
No-bake Raw Blueberry Cake
Pear and Almond Strudel.jpg
Pear and Almond Strudel
Pineapple Curd Meringue Cupcakes.jpg
Pineapple Curd Meringue Cupcakes
Raspberry Marshmallow Slice.jpg
Raspberry Marshmallow Slice
Whipped Ricotta Verrine.jpg
Whipped Ricotta Verrine
Rolled Chocolate Crepes with Summer Stone-fruit.jpg
Rolled Chocolate Crepes with Summer Stone-fruit
Marbled Chocolate Cheesecake.jpg
Marbled Chocolate Cheesecake with Caramel Mirror Glaze
Bombe Alaska.jpg
Bombe Alaska
Pavlova Platter.jpg
Pavlova Platter
Coconut Pannacotta with Mango Coulis and Caramelised Mango.jpg
Coconut Pannacotta with Mango Coulis and Caramelised Mango
Christmas Log.jpg
Christmas Log
Rosé Granita.jpg
Rosé Granita
Raspberry Mousse Cake.jpg
Raspberry Mousse Cake
No-bake Cherry Cheesecake.jpg
No-bake Cherry Cheesecake
Website Tile - Fried Bananas.jpg
Fried Bananas
moscato-poached nectarines with vanilla cream social.jpg
Moscato-Poached Nectarines with Vanilla Cream
Mango Panna Cotta.jpg
Mango Panna Cotta
Watermelon Ice Cream.jpg
Watermelon Ice Cream
Pistachio, Lime and Coconut Cheesecake Squares.jpg
Pistachio, Lime and Coconut Cheesecake Squares
TILE - Crunchy Caramel Nut Popcorn.jpg
Crunchy Caramel Nut Popcorn
Website Tile - Lamington Mousse.jpg
Lamington Mousse
Chocolate Coated Fruity Popcorn Bars.jpg
Chocolate Coated Fruity Popcorn Bars
Website Tile - Choc Meringue Tarts with Toasted Meringue - Copy.jpeg
Choc Hazelnut Tart with Toasted Meringue
Jaffa Cakes.jpg
Jaffa Cakes
Strawberry Kombucha Cake (Social).jpg
Strawberry Kombucha Cake
rustic-plum-cake-on-wooden-background-with-plums-around-picture-id1015585346.jpg
Plum Crumble Slice
baked chocolate cheesecake.jpg
Baked Chocolate Cheesecake
Website Tile - Chocolate Croissant Pudding.jpg
Chocolate Croissant Pudding
Website Tile - Honey Nut Baked Apples.jpg
Honey Nut Baked Apples
apple-crumble-picture-id467332803 (1).jpg
Classic Apple Crumble
Website Tile - Rhubarb and Raspberry Cobbler.jpg
Rhubarb and Raspberry Cobbler
Website Tile - Fluffy Lemon Ricotta Pancakes with Lemon Curd.jpg
Fluffy Lemon Ricotta Pancakes with Lemon Curd
Website Tile - Chocolate Mug Cake.jpeg
Chocolate Mug Cake
122 Teurgoule-3 square Large.jpeg
Teurgoule (Baked Rice Pudding) with Cinnamon Stewed Apples
Delicious-vegan-carrot-and-tangerine-sponge-cake-with-ground-almonds.-1341791821_6000x4000 square Large.jpeg
Wholemeal Mandarin and Carrot Loaf Cake
115 Gingerbread Christmas-4 square.jpg
Gingerbread Christmas Celebration Cake
131 Cocolemon Mess-8 square.jpg
Cocolemon Mess
107 Choc Cherry Cheesecake-2 square.jpg
Choc Cherry Cheesecake
111 Grilled summer fruit pavlova-5 square.jpg
Grilled Summer Fruit Pavlova with Coconut Cream
110 Grilled Fruit with honey labneh-4 aquare.jpg
Grilled fruit with honey labneh and pistachio dukkah
Rustic-Apple,-Blueberry-and-Raspberry-Custard-Danishes-on-Slate-Platter-1395084907_6000x4000 square.jpg
Air Fryer Blueberry Cheesecake Danish Pastries
Mango-Coconut-Ladoo--sweet-balls-made-of-mango-puree,-desiccated-coconut-and-condensed-milk-1253126248_6000x4000 square.jpg
Mango Coconut Ladoo
Website Tile - Matcha Strawberry Cheesecake Slice.jpg
Matcha Strawberry Cheesecake Slice
Recipe-image103.jpg
Mango and Passionfruit Trifle with Chantilly Cream
Recipe-image101.jpg
Summer Berry Pavlova Roll
Recipe-image99.jpg
No-bake Chocolate Mosaic Cake
Recipe-image105.jpg
Spiced Rum Cake
Website Tile - Loukoumades.jpeg
Loukoumades
iStock-1130995741 SQUARE.jpg
Three ingredient Rockmelon Popsicles
Baked-Pears-in-Puff-Pastry-1310714310_1800x2106 square.jpg
Baked Pears in Puff Pastry
Dark-chocolate-mousse-with-berries-and-cream-1332130301_7360x4912 square.jpeg
Four Ingredient Nutella Mousse
Website Tile - Red Velvet Tarts.jpg
Red Velvet Tarts
iStock-1320170704 square.jpg
Homemade Strawberry Pop Tarts
Website Tile - Banana Pops.jpg
Banana Pops
Lemon Curd Easter Cookies.jpg
Lemon Curd Easter Cookies
Sweet Cinnamon Buns.jpg
Sweet Cinnamon Buns
White Chocolate and Coconut Cake.jpg
White Chocolate and Coconut Cake
Peanut Butter Stuffed Dates.jpg
Peanut Butter Stuffed Dates
Cottontail Bunny Cookies.jpg
Cottontail Bunny Cookies
Bunny Face Gingerbread Cookies.jpg
Bunny Face Gingerbread Cookies
Easter Bunny’s Carrot Loaf Cake.jpg
Easter Bunny’s Carrot Loaf Cake
Carrot Meringue Pie.jpg
Carrot Meringue Pie
Website Tile - Triple Raspberry Pancakes.jpg
Triple Raspberry Pancakes
Easter Bunny Hot Chocolate.jpg
Easter Bunny Hot Chocolate
Lemony Easter cupcakes.jpg
Lemony Easter cupcakes
Marbled Chocolate Meringues with Choc-Hazelnut Cream.jpg
Marbled Chocolate Meringues with Choc-Hazelnut Cream
No-Bake Mini Bird’s Nest Cheesecakes.jpg
No-Bake Mini Bird’s Nest Cheesecakes
Sweet-plum-dumplings-in-metal-bowl-on-wooden-table-1006225460_5616x3744 square.jpeg
Plum Dumplings
Website Tile - Berry, Plum and Apple Crumble.jpeg
Berry, Plum and Apple Crumble
Traditional-Arabic-dessert-Umm-Ali-in-a-white-ceramic-form-decorated-with-nuts-on-a-light-gray-background-1490124906_2136x1408 square.jpg
Pistachio, Orange & Apricot Pudding
Custard-lime-curd-served-with-pancakes-on-a-light-background.-Rustic-style.-1480185119_2197x1368 square.jpeg
Lemon & Lime Curd
Website Tile - Red Wine Poached Pears.jpeg
Red Wine Poached Pears
Website Tile - Chocolate Self Saucing Pudding.jpeg
Chocolate Self-Saucing Pudding
Rhubarb-Crumble-177139387_5616x3744 square.jpeg
Rhubarb Crumble
Website Tile - Cottage Cheese Pancakes with Poached Rhubarb.jpeg
Cottage Cheese Pancakes with Poached Rhubarb
Pastry-tongs-holding-apple-turnover-178575724_3866x2578 square.jpeg
Apple Turnovers
Homemade-pudding-made-by-leftovers-bread-and-strawberries-1385363664_3869x2579 square.jpeg
Strawberry Bread Pudding
Strawberry-puff-mille-feuille-with-strawberry.-821353264_3869x2579 square.jpeg
Cheat’s Strawberry Mille-Feuille
Website Tile - Strawberry and Chocolate Yoghurt Bark.jpg
Strawberry and Chocolate Yoghurt Bark
Choc-Hazelnut Baked Envy Apples - Web Tile.jpg
Choc-Hazelnut Baked envyTM Apples
Melon Ice Cream_1.jpg
Melon Ice Cream
Mini_Chocolate_Ganache_Tarts.jpg
Mini Chocolate Ganache Tarts
Matcha-Limoncello-Tiramisu.jpg
Matcha Limoncello Tiramisu
STRAWB~1.JPG
Strawberry and Watermelon Patisserie
Classic Christmas Trifle.JPG
Classic Christmas Trifle
Eggnogg-Mousse.jpg
Eggnog Mousse
Beigli .JPG
Beigli – Christmas Poppy Seed and Walnut Roll Cakes
Caramelised-Pineapple.jpg
Caramelised Pineapple
Glazed-Mango-Cheesecake.jpg
Glazed Mango Cheesecake
Apple-&-Pistachio-Cake.jpg
Apple & Pistachio Cake
Panettone-French-Toast-with-Chantilly-Cream.jpg
Panettone French Toast with Chantilly Cream
Salted-Caramel-&-Almond-Pavlova-Stack.jpg
Salted Caramel & Almond Pavlova Stack
Tasmanian Blueberry Ice Cream - Web Tile.jpg
Tasmanian Blueberry Ice Cream
Website Tile - No Bake Easter Cheesecake.jpg
No Bake Easter Cheesecake
Website Tiles - Sweet Easter Swirls.jpg
Sweet Easter Swirls
Nanaimo Bars - Tile.jpeg
Nanaimo Bars
Web Tile - Strawberry Bites.jpg
Strawberry Bites
Luscious Lemon Bars - Web Tile.jpg
Luscious Lemon Bars
Sticky Date Cake with Toffee Sauce - Web Tile.jpg
Sticky Date Cake with Toffee Sauce
Honeyed Apple and Thyme Tarts - Web Tile.png
Honeyed Apple and Thyme Tarts
Lemon Chia Pancakes with Citrus Glaze - Web Tile.jpg
Lemon Chia Pancakes with Citrus Glaze